Skip to content
rhyme.news
Monday 2 November 202613 stories20 patterns in the libraryEvery story cross-referenced with the historical record
Historical pattern · 2000 – 2023

The boom-time technology mega-merger

A technology company uses boom-era valuations to buy a strategic supplier or rival for tens of billions, betting on a single demand story, and then faces a long multi-jurisdiction review. The deals end in roughly equal measure: closed and written off, blocked or abandoned, or closed and compounding.

The cases

6 episodes
  1. 2000

    AOL agrees to buy Time Warner

    AOL used its internet-era stock to agree an all-stock purchase of Time Warner valued at about $165bn, announced in January 2000.

    What happened next: Closed in January 2001 after FTC conditions. About $99bn was written off in 2002, and the companies separated by 2009.write-off

  2. 2000

    JDS Uniphase agrees to buy SDL

    JDSU agreed in July 2000 to buy laser maker SDL for about $41bn in stock at the peak of the optical-fibre boom.

    What happened next: Closed in February 2001 after the US Justice Department required a pump-laser divestiture. JDSU then wrote down roughly $50bn of goodwill as the telecom bust deepened.write-off

  3. 2016

    Qualcomm agrees to buy NXP

    Qualcomm agreed to buy NXP Semiconductors, later raising the cash offer to about $44bn, which required approval in China.

    What happened next: China's SAMR never approved the deal during the US–China trade dispute. Qualcomm abandoned it in July 2018 and paid a $2bn break fee.blocked

  4. 2020

    Nvidia agrees to buy Arm

    Nvidia agreed to buy Arm from SoftBank for about $40bn in cash and stock.

    What happened next: The FTC sued, and UK, EU and Chinese regulators raised concerns. The deal was abandoned in February 2022.blocked

  5. 2020

    AMD agrees to buy Xilinx

    AMD agreed an all-stock purchase of Xilinx valued at about $35bn.

    What happened next: Closed in February 2022 after conditional approval from SAMR, by then worth about $49bn. The deal was broadly judged a success.compounds

  6. 2022

    Broadcom agrees to buy VMware

    Broadcom agreed to buy VMware for about $61bn in equity, or about $69bn including debt.

    What happened next: SAMR gave the final approval with conditions in November 2023, about 18 months after the announcement. The deal became a large source of value for Broadcom.compounds

How these cases resolved

Closes and compounds34%
Closes, then most of the price is written off33%
Blocked or abandoned under regulatory pressure33%

Share of the 6 cases above that resolved this way. Small samples: treat as a prior, not a forecast.

Signals that mark this pattern
  • Acquirer pays largely in shares valued at or near record highs
  • Strategic case rests on a single demand boom
  • Closing timeline of a year or more, with approval needed in China
  • Sector share prices falling around the announcement
  • Acquirer shareholders mark down the bid soon after it leaks
The lesson
A boom-time mega-merger is a bet on both the cycle and the regulators, and history has split the results almost evenly among failure to close, closing and regret, and closing and success.

Stories echoing this pattern